The Best Sword & Sorcery Comics of All Time!
I rank the best sword & sorcery comics of all time in two categories; colour and black & white. Your nominations are encouraged.
Two Categories:
1.) Colour comics
2.) Black & white
The Rules:
Nominate single issues or short, (relatively) self-contained storyarcs. List title, issue number(s) & creative team; writer, artist, inker.
Title of story(arc), publication date & publisher are nice to have, but not mandatory. Basically, the more details, the better, so folks can track them down.Nominations must be by the same creative team.
European and British comics are permitted.
Here are some of my nominations, vaguely in order of preference. I will keep adding as candidates occur to me.
COLOUR COMICS:
Conan (Marvel) #24: ‘The Song of Red Sonja’ by Barry Smith & Roy Thomas
Conan (Marvel) #20: ‘The Black Hound of Vengeance’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith & Dan Adkins
Kull the Destroyer (Marvel -1973) #11: ‘By this Axe...I Rule!’ by Roy Thomas & Mike Ploog
Conan (Marvel) #14-15: ‘The Green Empress of Melnibone’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith & Sal Buscema
Conan (Marvel) #7: ‘The Lurker Within’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith, Dan Adkins & Sal Buscema
Conan (Marvel) #11: ‘Rogues in the House’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith & Sal Buscema
Conan (Marvel) #4: ‘The Tower of the Elephant’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith & Sal Buscema
Conan (Marvel) #19: ‘Hawks from the Sea’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith & Dan Adkins
Conan (Marvel) #8: ‘The Keepers of the Crypt’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith & Tom Sutton + Tom Palmer
Conan (Marvel) #5: ‘Zukala’s Daughter’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith & Frank Giacioa
Conan (Marvel) #6: ‘Devil-Wings Over Shadizar’ by Roy Thomas, Barry Smith & Sal Buscema
Kull the Conqueror Vol. 1 (Marvel - 1972 ) #2-3 + Monsters of the Prowl #16 featuring Kull: ‘The Shadow Kingdom/The Death Dance of Thulsa Doom’ by Roy Thomas with Marie & John Severin
Creatures on the Loose #10 featuring Kull the Conqueror (Marvel - 1971): ‘The Skull of Silence’ by Roy Thomas & Bernie Wrightson
Supernatural Thrillers (Marvel) #3: ‘Valley of the Worm’ by Roy Thomas/Gerry Conway, Gil Kane & Ernie Chua/Chan - with thanks to Jan Scherpenhuizen
Kull the Conqueror (Marvel - 1982) #2: ‘The Blood of Kings’ by Doug Moench & John Bolton
Conan (Marvel) #37: ‘The Curse of the Golden Skull’ by Roy Thomas & Neal Adams - with thanks to Bill Smith
Solomon Kane in ‘The Serpent Ring’ #1-4 (Titan - 2025?) by Patrick Zircher
Spawn The Dark Ages #1-6 (Image - 2025) by Liam Sharp
Beowulf Dragon-Slayer (DC - 1975?): ‘Valley in the Shadow of Death’ by Michael Uslan & Ricardo Villamonte
Sword of Sorcery #1 (DC - 1975) #1: Fafhrd & the Grey Mouser in ‘The Price of Pain’s Ease’ by Denny O’Neil, Howard Chaykin & the Crusty Bunkers - Classic cover by Mike Kaluta
Sword of Socery (DC - 1975) #4: Fafhrd & the Grey Mouser in ‘The Sunken Land’ by Denny O’Neil & Walt Simonson
Sword of Socery (DC - 1975) #4: Young Fafhrd (back-up feature) in ‘The Prophecy’ by (Young) Walt Simonson
Sword of Socery (DC - 1975) #5: Mouser (back-up feature) in ‘The Mouse Alone’ by George Effinger, Jim Starlin & Al Milgrom
Weird Worlds (DC - 1975?) #10: Iron Wolf in ‘Home World’ by Denny O’Neil & Howard Chaykin - Classic cover by Mike Kaluta
Marvel Premiere (Marvel) #33-34: Solomon Kane in ‘Red Shadows’ by Roy Thomas & Howard Chaykin
BLACK & WHITE
Savage Tales (Marvel) #2 & 3: Conan in ‘Red Nails’ by Barry Smith & Roy Thomas
Savage Tales (Marvel) #5: Conan in ‘The Dweller in the Dark’ by Roy Thomas & Barry Smith. Yes, I know this was originally published in the colour Conan, but it was originally intended for ST and for b&w.
Savage Tales (Marvel) #1: Conan in ‘The Frost Giant’s Daugher’ by Roy Thomas & Barry Smith
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #5: Conan in ‘A Witch Shall be Born’ by Roy Thomas, John Buscema & Tony DeZuniga’s Tribe
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #4: Conan in ‘Iron Shadows in the Moonlight’ by Roy Thomas, John Buscema & Alfredo Alcala
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #26 & 27: Conan in ‘Beyond the Black River’ by Roy Thomas, John Buscema & Tony DeZuniga
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #2: Conan in ‘Black Colossos’ by Roy Thomas, John Buscema & Alfredo Alcala
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #20: Conan in ‘The Slithering Shadow’ by Roy Thomas, John Buscema & Alfedo Alcala
Savage Sword of Conan(Marvel) #12: Conan in ‘The Haunters of Castle Crimson’ by Roy Thomas, John Buscema & Alfredo Alcala
Savage Sword of Conan(Marvel) #15: Conan in ‘The Devil in Iron’ by Roy Thomas, John Buscema & Alfredo Alcala
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #16-19: Conan in ‘The People of the Black Circle’ by Roy Thomas, John Buscema & Alfredo Alcala
Bizarre Adventures (Marvel) #26 featuring Kull: ‘Demon in a Silvered Glass’ by Doug Moench & John Bolton
Savage Sword of Conan (Titan - 2024?): Conan in ‘The Wuthering’ by Liam Sharp
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #62: Conan in ‘Temple of the Tiger’ by Michael Fleisher, John Buscema & Ernie Chan
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #61: Conan in ‘The Wizard Fiend of Zingara’ by Michael Fleisher & John Buscema (pencils & inks!)
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #30: Conan in ‘The Scarlet Citadel’ by Roy Thomas & Frank Brunner with thanks to Paulo Stone
Dracula Lives (Marvel) #3 featuring Solomon Kane (back-up) in ‘Castle of the Undead’ by Roy Thomas, Alan Weiss & the Crusty Bunkers
Monsters Unleashed (Marvel) #1 featuring Solomon Kane (back-up) in ‘Skulls in the Stars’ by Roy Thomas & Ralph Reese
Eerie #66 featuring El Cid (Warren - 1975) by Budd Lewis & Gonzalo Mayo
Eerie #59 featuring Dax the Damned (Warren - 1974) by Budd Lewis & Esteban Maroto - Recommended by G. Taylor (on substack)
Savage Sword of Conan (Marvel) #6: ‘People of the Dark’ by Roy Thomas & Alex Nino with thanks to Jan Scherpenhuizen














Can't believe you didn't include Esteban Maroto's Dax the Damned (originally published in Europe as Manly), which ran as a serial in Eerie and was collected in Eerie #59. Maroto was a better artist than Mayo (the iconic cover for Eerie #41 was taken from a panel in the Dax story "Chess") and the stories were very different from Conan with their existentialist edge. The Dax story Death Rides The Night which ended the series is sometimes cited as one of the ten best S&S comic book stories.
I acknowledge Maroto is a better artist than Mayo...or at least more original. But I first encountered El Cid and Mayo as a young, impressionable 13-year-old in that glorious summer of '75 and it blew my tiny eggshell mind. Those kinds of adolescent impressions are ineasible, making objectivity difficult, if not impossible. Dax, on the other hand, I never got around to reading until this year as a cantankerous, reasonably critical 64-year-old, on relative command of my mental faculties. Hence the difference. I have, however, been a big Maroto fans since the sane year when I saw his Warren work.